Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake

Another birthday, another cheesecake. For my brother-in-law Jim’s birthday, I scoured countless recipes until I happened upon this recipe involving one of his favorite things – Reese’s peanut butter cups. I decided to ignore the nutrition information on the page, as bad as it may be. It’s for a special occasion, after all.

I followed the recipe with only a couple of exceptions. I have no idea how many crushed Oreos it takes to make 4 & 1/2 cups. So, I used an entire package minus the two that I ate. The crust for this cheesecake turned out beautifully.

I also changed the baking method to the way I’ve found to be foolproof, thanks to Mary Crownover’s book. I baked the cheesecake at 350 degrees for 15 minutes. Then, I decreased the temperature to 200 degrees and baked for 2 hours. Next, I ran a thin, narrow spatula around the sides of the cake and returned it to the oven, turning the oven off. After two more hours, it was time to refrigerate overnight.

Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake | Bake or Break

The other change I made was the topping. I thought that a peanut butter cup cheesecake needed a chocolate topping. So, I whipped up one of the quickest, easiest chocolate toppings you could ever hope to make. In a saucepan over low heat, melt 5 ounces of milk chocolate chips with 1/4 cup of sour cream, stirring constantly. That’s it. Just spread it over the cheesecake and return it to the refrigerator to set up.

I wish that I’d had a bit more crust for the sides of the pan so that the cheesecake would have been entirely surrounded by chocolate, much like a peanut butter cup. However it looks, it is an incredible cheesecake. It has a wonderful, creamy texture. It was definitely a hit with everyone, including the birthday boy. And now, I have a bit of cheesecake baking reprieve. Well, until my sister’s birthday next month.

Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake

Prep Time: 45 minutes

Cook Time: 2 hours, 15 minutes

Yield: 12 to 14 servings

Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake

Ingredients

    For the crust:
  • 4 & 1/2 cups crushed Oreo cookies
  • 1 cup chopped roasted peanuts
  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter, melted
  • For the filling:
  • 32 ounces cream cheese, softened
  • 5 large eggs
  • 1 & 1/2 cups firmly packed light brown sugar
  • 1 cup smooth peanut butter
  • 1/2 cup heavy cream
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 12 regular-sized peanut butter cups, broken into small pieces
  • For the topping:
  • 5 ounces milk chocolate
  • 1/4 cup sour cream

Instructions

To make the crust:

Preheat oven to 350°.

Place cookies and peanuts in the bowl of a food processor. Pulse until combined. Add melted butter and pulse until combined.

Press the crust firmly onto the bottom and up the sides of a 10-inch springform pan.

To make the filling:

Using an electric mixer on medium speed, beat cream cheese until smooth. Add eggs, one at a time, mixing well after each addition.

Add sugar, peanut butter, cream, and vanilla. Mix until smooth. Stir in peanut butter cups.

Pour filling into prepared crust.

Bake for 15 minutes.

Decrease oven temperature to 200 degrees. Bake for 2 hours.

Turn off oven. Remove cheesecake from oven and run a knife around the edges of the cheesecake. Place cheesecake back in the oven for 2 hours.

Cover and refrigerate overnight.

To make the topping:

Place chocolate chips and sour cream in a small saucepan. Cook over low heat, stirring constantly, until smooth.

Spread over the top of the cheesecake. Return cheesecake to refrigerator for 30 minutes, or until the topping is set.

Notes

Recipe adapted from Food.com.

http://www.bakeorbreak.com/2006/11/reeses-peanut-butter-cup-cheesecake/

55 Comments

  1. peabody November 12, 2006 Reply

    I own that cheesecake cookbook. I have yet to make anything from it.
    That cheesecake looks super yummy, my hubby would be all over that, for PBC are his favorite.

  2. Christine November 12, 2006 Reply

    Oh my goodness! I’m drooling.

  3. Ellie November 13, 2006 Reply

    This looks amazing! The light reflecting off the top layer of chocolate is making me totally ga-ga for this sweet treat!

  4. Gigi November 13, 2006 Reply

    OMG! This looks sooo good. I was looking for something different to serve at Thanksgiving and I think this will be it!

    Did you bake this in a water bath like the original recipe states? Or, does your baking method avoid that messy detail?

  5. jennifer November 13, 2006 Reply

    Gigi, I didn’t use a water bath. The method I described works very well without having to do that.

  6. Ivonne November 13, 2006 Reply

    Ohhhhhhhhhhhh! That’s all I can think of to say … Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh!

  7. deb November 14, 2006 Reply

    Holy fuhreaking goodness that sounds good. Now, I have to hide this find from my husband who would absolutely die happy if I made this.

    I also love a thick crust on cheesecakes.

  8. Robyn November 14, 2006 Reply

    That looks so nice! I’ve been wanting to get ‘I Love Cheesecake’, heard it was a good book.

  9. Brilynn November 14, 2006 Reply

    I want chocolate now. Thanks a lot.

  10. Nan November 14, 2006 Reply

    Sooooooo good!

    Jennifer, Jim loved the cheesecake as we all did! It really made the occasion and may be your best cheesecake yet. Thanks for taking time to make Jim’s birthday so special by baking for him! You know how he loves Reese’s…he’s still talking about it. Also, I hope to see this recipe at future gatherings, too.

    For other visitors to this website…MAKE the cheesecake and enjoy it like we did!

  11. Abby November 14, 2006 Reply

    Oh. My. Gosh.

  12. lisa November 15, 2006 Reply

    Wow that looks fantastic! I’m gonna have to try that one! I love Reeses and cheesecakes. What a great combo!

  13. donna December 10, 2006 Reply

    Enjoyed reading the comments.
    Would someone please post the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake recipe or email it to me?

  14. Di March 15, 2007 Reply

    I’m going to be baking this cheesecake tonight. Last year I donated a dessert a month to the Creative Arts Auction. This month is the last one and I wanted to make something special. I think this is it! The only problem is, I will be giving it away without a taste test. Oh well, I guess I will have to make one for our next special occasion. I love RPBC!

  15. Di April 30, 2007 Reply

    I baked this cheesecake and it IS WONDERFUL!!! I made the first one to give away and my family drooled over it so much, I had to bake another one for us. I’m baking one tonight as a gift to give at a closing I have tomorrow. I used the chocolate topping as suggested and then topped with more chopped peanut butter cups.

  16. Jane September 15, 2007 Reply

    I sell cheesecakes and I think this cake sounds delicious, I will definitly give it a try. Thanks

  17. Jessica September 30, 2007 Reply

    Hi…just a quick question about Crownover’s baking method (the 15 min. at 350, 2 hours at 200, and then 2 hours cooling in the oven method)…

    Do you think this would work for just about any standard cheesecake being made in a springform pan? Can one just take most cheesecake recipes, toss out their baking instructions and do this instead?

    A separate question, which you might not have any experience with, but I thought I’d ask anyway…my oven is small (a 9X13 is the biggest pan that will fit in there)…do you think there might be anything about the smaller oven that might affect how the cheesecake bakes?

    Thanks..loving your blog, especially now that I finally have an oven again!

  18. jennifer September 30, 2007 Reply

    Jessica, I certainly am not a cheesecake expert. However, I would think that as a general rule, the baking method could work for most cheesecake recipes. I would probably keep a close eye on it while it bakes, but it’s certainly a worthwhile experiment.

    I don’t have any experience with your size oven. The only potential problem I see is that whatever you’re baking will be closer to the heating element than it would in a larger oven. With such a long cooking time, that probably wouldn’t be as big a deal with a cheesecake as it would with something that requires a short baking time, like cookies. If the top of your cheesecake starts getting too brown too quickly, you could have some aluminum foil handy to cover the top loosely.

    I hope that helps. Let me know how it works for you!

  19. Jessica October 3, 2007 Reply

    Thanks so much for the tips…the crownover method worked beautifully. The only problem with the small oven (actually a friend’s, not the one I talked about originally) was that her rack was not very sturdy…and when I pulled the cheesecake out to check it, the rack collapsed and sent the cheesecake sliding to the bottom of the oven. Fortunately, it all stayed in the pan, but it definitely cracked. Good thing we were putting a topping on it!

    We served it to our Chinese teachers (we are language students in China) and they loved it.

    Thanks for the help, it’s much appreciated. And I LOVE your blog.:D

  20. jennifer October 4, 2007 Reply

    You’re welcome, Jessica! I’m glad it turned out well, despite the rack disaster.

  21. Rachelle ~ Ldylvbgr March 5, 2008 Reply

    Just from the look on my Husband’s face when we saw this, I knew I had to make it. Mmm, it’s really good! I did my topping like yours, but doubled it.

  22. Lindsay May 23, 2008 Reply

    I’m preparing to try this recipe next week and am looking forward to it! I have an Oreo question, though:

    Did you put them in the food processor whole, or did you split them and remove the cream filling before processing them? (My mom said she did that before because she had had problems with the filling melting, running and leaking during baking).

  23. jennifer May 24, 2008 Reply

    Lindsay, I put the Oreos in the food processor whole and didn’t have any problems. Another option is the Nabisco chocolate wafers. They can be hard to find, but they’re great for crusts. I used them for that delicious icebox cake, too.

  24. Lindsay May 25, 2008 Reply

    Thanks! Another question …

    In the crust, did you use peanuts that had salt on them? I bought peanuts that I thought were unsalted, but I was wrong!

    (By the way, I found the wafers, but they were expired … grrrrr … so I am going to stick with the Oreos).

  25. jennifer May 25, 2008 Reply

    Lindsay, I’m not entirely sure I remember if the peanuts were salted or not. If I was able to find roasted peanuts that weren’t salted, then I would have used those. Otherwise, I would have gone with whatever I could find. Hope that helps!

  26. Jennie July 8, 2008 Reply

    I made this last night with your topping and baking suggestions – can’t wait to try it out tonight and see how it tastes!

    Did you use 12 regular peanut butter cups or the miniature ones?

  27. novilla November 26, 2008 Reply

    I made this for Thanksgiving, I didn’t need to bring a dessert, but could not resist. Mine did crack though, I was disappointed, but with the chocolate sauce no one will be able to tell. My pan was very full. I have only made one other cheesecake before, so I am nervous to cut into it.

  28. novilla December 6, 2008 Reply

    I am making it again as we are going to a friends house for lunch tomorrow and I had most of the ingredients on hand. I had made a different peanut butter cup cake and the receipe called for Nutty Butters (those cookies shaped like peanuts with the peanut butter middle) and butter I wonder if that would be toooo much peanut butter flavor…

  29. kefi December 13, 2008 Reply

    I made this the other week. Oh my freakin goodness. Everybody absolutely loved it and I never thought I could make something so freaking good. If you haven’t tried it, do it, you definitly will not regret it. YUUUUUMMMMMM!

  30. Jennifer L. April 22, 2009 Reply

    I know this is an old post, but may I ask a question? I want to make this for a large b-day party so I’m thinking of doing a 9 inch atop a 10 inch. If I’m careful to make both sizes the same depth, do you think it will affect the baking time? I’m hoping to bake them together, but I don’t want to overcook the 9 inch in order to get the 10 inch one done. What do you think? (LOVE this blog, BTW–just discovered it.)

  31. jennifer April 22, 2009 Reply

    Jennifer, I’m glad you found me! I’m not sure I would attempt to bake the chesecakes at the same time. Cheesecakes can be so temperamental that I wouldn’t want to risk it.

  32. Jennifer L. April 23, 2009 Reply

    Thanks for your advice. My instincts were telling me the same thing, and this dessert is too important for me to experiment on (as I often do with smaller family things). I have the 10″ in the oven now and will do the other one later this evening. I decided to do an 8″ on top; when I stacked the pans, the 9″ didn’t give enough of a layering effect. I really appreciate your willingness to bounce ideas around and share advice. I usually do these things all on my own–mostly with success but sometimes with disappointments–as I’m sure you understand!

  33. Jennifer L. April 23, 2009 Reply

    Thanks for your advice. My instincts were telling me the same thing, and this dessert is too important for me to experiment on (as I often do with smaller family things). I have the 10″ in the oven now and will do the other one later this evening. I decided to do an 8″ on top; when I stacked the pans, the 9″ didn’t give enough of a layering effect. I really appreciate your willingness to bounce ideas around and share advice. I usually do these things all on my own–mostly with success but sometimes with disappointments–as I’m sure you understand!

  34. Theresa December 30, 2009 Reply

    omg this looks sooo good! my man n myself LOVES reese cups! i am so goin 2 try that! yummy yummy!!

  35. fbginrv December 1, 2010 Reply

    I’ve made this cheesecake three Christmases in a row and it is the BOMB!

  36. Vicky December 22, 2010 Reply

    I made this cheesecake for my boyfriend’s birthday and it was delicious. Incredibly rich so one slice really does go a long way – but absolutely amazing. Probably the most impressive thing I’ve ever made.

  37. jodes January 2, 2012 Reply

    I made this on New Year’s day for a dinner (to be held the day after). Everyone loved it. It was delicious and very, very rich. I looked at the original recipe linked from this page, but decided to go with your suggestion of a chocolate topping (made from semi-sweet chocolate chips as I had no milk chips). Thank you for that! Extra pb cups on the top would of been too much.

    So glad I came across your blog! I will be a regular visitor :)

    Thanks and Happy 2012!

  38. marie July 13, 2014 Reply

    I made this cheesecake exactly by the recipe and it is the bomb!!! Not a thing wrong with this smooth, creamy cheesecake. Next time I think I will make a peanut butter glaze to drizzle over the chocolate simply because you just can’t have too much peanut butter. Thanks for sharing the recipe.

    • Author
      Jennifer McHenry July 14, 2014 Reply

      So glad you liked it, Marie! I’m such a sucker for peanut butter and chocolate!

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>