Weekly Mix: Fishs Eddy and a Haagen Dazs Moment for Me

If anyone asks me, I will quickly tell them that Fishs Eddy is my favorite shop in NYC. I have a long-standing love of dishes and serving pieces and the like. Even with limited storage space, I just can’t seem to get enough. Luckily, after I started this blog, I immediately had good reason to collect even more dishes and pedestals and other completely justifiable things for serving and displaying baked goods.

For the last couple of months, I’ve been very happily sharing my experiences with Haagen Dazs’ Moment for Me project. I’ve told you all about the canning class and Italian cooking class. There’s been much more, and I’ll get to it all.

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

One of my recent Moment for Me boxes had a tiny little envelope inside that I found after excitedly riffling through all the other items. Inside that tiny envelope was a gift card to Fishs Eddy. Do they know me, or what? My birthday was earlier this week, and I decided to give myself a little birthday treat with a trip to Fishs Eddy.

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

If you’ve never been to Fishs Eddy, here’s the deal. They have dishes. Lots of dishes. Some are vintage, some are new, and some are really cheap. They also have flatware, glassware, serving pieces, and much more. They even have cow-shaped creamers and butter molds and plenty of other fun items.

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

But, the shop isn’t just about the dishes. They’ve taken a lot of care to make it a beautiful shop, too. There are many portraits, vintage signs, old crates, and more scattered among and above the stacks of dishes. It’s jam-packed with good stuff, but it doesn’t seem too crowded. If you can go on a weekday, you’ll avoid the weekend crowds, too. And, if you’re just visiting the city, they’ll ship to you.

I could go on and on about this shop, but I’ll just let the photos do most of the talking for me. Enjoy!

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

Fishs Eddy | Bake or Break

Thanks so much to Haagen Dazs for my shopping spree! I picked up several items that you’ll likely see soon on BoB. If you’d like to visit Fishs Eddy, they are located at 889 Broadway at 19th Street in Manhattan. You can also order many of their items directly from their website.

I have been chosen by Haagen Dazs as an ambassador for their Moment for Me campaign. I was provided with a gift card for Fishs Eddy. This post is not sponsored by or affiliated with Fishs Eddy, although it is my happy place. All opinions are my own.

Be sure to share your own #HDMoment on social media. Your moment may be featured by Haagen Dazs!

Don't miss a recipe! Sign up for free email updates.



  1. JEP August 30, 2013 Reply

    Love the crates in your pictures. What a fun store! I can see why you got excited about the gift card. Belated Happy Birthday!

  2. Sharon August 30, 2013 Reply

    Ditto ditto ditto on Fish’s Eddy being the most awesome corner store in NYC. I happily spent a rapturous hour and an half there last time I visited, and had a grin on my face for the rest of the trip. Lucky you!

  3. again with the jealousy.

    Fishs Eddy is SUCH a cool place! I’ve only been once and I kneeew it was dangerously awesome!

  4. Colleen September 1, 2013 Reply

    Agree! Just love Fishs Eddy. I can spend hours in there.

  5. Michelle September 2, 2013 Reply

    Happy belated birthday!

  6. ellen patton September 5, 2013 Reply

    I went to Fishs Eddy last year for the first time — love!

  7. beverleyann September 10, 2013 Reply

    Hands down my favourite store in NYC. I love my stoneware plates and cocktail recipe glasses. There has never been a time I have served dinner or a drink to someone in them without the guest mentioning how fabulous they are!

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *